← All Articles
SEO15 November 20264 min read

Does Google Penalise AI Content

No. Google judges a page on whether it helps the searcher, however it was made. It acts against pages churned out at scale to game rankings, and AI makes that mistake easy to make.

Google does not penalise a page because AI helped write it. Its published guidance says it rewards helpful content however it was produced, and what it acts against is content made mainly to manipulate rankings, which AI makes very easy to produce by accident.

So the real question is whether your AI-assisted page is better than what already ranks. A raw AI draft almost never is.

What Google has said

In February 2023, Google Search Central published its guidance on AI-generated content. Using AI or automation is not against Google's guidelines, and its systems look at the quality of the content rather than how it was made.

The same guidance draws one line. Using automation, AI included, to produce content where the main purpose is to manipulate search rankings breaks Google's spam policies.

Where AI sites get caught

In March 2024, Google added a spam policy called scaled content abuse. It covers producing large numbers of pages mainly to rank rather than to help people, and Google says it applies whether the pages come from AI, from people or from both. The same update folded the helpful content system into Google's core ranking systems.

This is the policy an AI content plan is most likely to trip. A site that publishes 100 near-identical pages where only the suburb name changes, or hundreds of articles answering questions nobody asked, is doing what the policy describes.

A suburb page earns its place when it holds something true about that suburb: jobs you did there, photos from those jobs, the questions locals actually ask. Swap the name and keep everything else, and you have built exactly what the policy targets.

What Google rewards

Google's guidance asks whether a page shows first-hand experience and real expertise, and whether the reader leaves with what they came for. Since December 2022, its quality rater guidelines have included experience in what Google calls E-E-A-T, which stands for experience, expertise, authoritativeness and trustworthiness.

Experience is the part AI cannot fake. It has never stood on your site, priced your job or taken the call from an unhappy customer. Your photos, your numbers, your opinions and your mistakes are what make a page worth ranking, and they have to come from you. I wrote more about that shift in how AI is killing generic marketing.

How to use AI without the risk

I use AI every day at Ignis, and it is very good at the slow parts of writing: research, outlines, first drafts and checking a page against the questions buyers ask. These are the rules I hold it to.

Every fact gets checked against a real source. AI will invent a statistic, a law or a date with total confidence.

Someone who knows the subject adds what only they know, such as a real job, a number from your own records or a photo you took.

The draft gets edited until it sounds like a person. That process is in how to edit AI-written copy.

One page per question. If two of your pages answer the same search, merge them into one better page.

Should you label it

Google does not require a label for a page to rank. Its guidance does encourage you to make clear who created a page, and to explain how automation was used where a reader would reasonably wonder about it.

For a business blog, the simplest test is the byline. Put a real name on every article, and make sure that person would happily defend every line in it on a sales call.

The clean-up

Open Search Console and sort your pages by impressions over the last three months. If a lot of your AI articles sit near the bottom, shown to almost nobody, Google is telling you something.

Pick the ones that answer a real buyer question and rewrite them with your own jobs, photos and numbers. Merge the ones that cover the same ground, and remove the ones nobody would miss. A smaller blog where every page earns its place does more for you than a big one full of filler, and the full clean-up is in what to do with an old blog nobody reads.

AI search tools

ChatGPT and Perplexity pull answers from pages that state things clearly and get the facts right. A thin, generic page is no more likely to be quoted by them than it is to rank on Google. How those tools pick their sources is in how to get cited by ChatGPT and Perplexity.

Use AI to reach a draft faster, then spend the time you saved on the first-hand detail only your business has. Done on every page, that turns AI into the reason you can publish more pages that rank.

David Eid

David Eid

Marketing Strategist · Founder of Ignis

Marketing strategist based in Sydney, Australia. Founder of Ignis - premium marketing that scales businesses. Our average client generates $3M+/year and 1M+ views/month.

SEOAIGoogle
Share

Get weekly marketing insights

No fluff. No spam. Strategies from someone who has done it. Delivered to your inbox every week.

Subscribe